1446 year 30 Рамазон | 2025 year 30 march, sunday
Regions:
Тошкент
ЎЗ UZ RU EN
Quran

A Literary Challenge: “Bring Something Like It”

10:41 / 30.11.2019 1147 Reading mode + -

Many people misunderstand the Quran’s literary challenge to produce something like it.  Many people assume it simply means writing something as “good” as the Quran.

Because of this, many skeptics point out – and rightly so – that literary value judgments are highly subjective.  If someone says that he thinks a certain selection of prose or poetry is better than the Quran, who can argue with him?  Isn’t it really a matter of personal judgment and taste?  Who is to be the arbiter?

The Quran’s challenge, however, is not simply to write something of equal literary merit, but rather to produce something like the Quran.

We can see this in all the verses of challenge.  Almighty Allah says:

'Say, “If mankind and jinn came together to produce the like of this Quran, they could never produce the like of it, even if they backed up one another.”' (Surah al-Isra, 88)

Allah says:

'Or do they say, “He invented it?” Say, “Then produce ten chapters like it, invented, and call upon whomever you can, besides Allah, if you are truthful.”' (Surah Hud, 13)

Allah says:

'Or do they say, “He has forged it”? Say, “Then produce a single chapter like it, and call upon whomever you can, apart from Allah, if you are truthful.”' (Surah Yunus, 38)

Allah says:

'And if you are in doubt about what We have revealed to Our servant, then produce a chapter like these, and call your witnesses apart from Allah, if you are truthful. But if you do not—and you will not—then beware the Fire whose fuel is people and stones, prepared for the disbelievers.' (Surah al-Baqarah, 23-24)

Therefore, it is not simply a matter of quality – it does not even have to be of equal merit! Similarity is all that matters.  What is required by the challenge is to achieve at least a comparable degree of the literary beauty, nobility, and sublimity of the Quran while at the same time emulating the Quran’s particular style.

It is possible to superficially mimic the style of the Quran, and many people have been successful in doing so – but all such attempts from the days of Musailimah to the present have proven to be silly and absurd, and have often invoked laughter and derision.  This is the unanimous consensus of everyone who has ever heard or read those attempts.

It is, likewise, possible for a person writing in Arabic to reach a great level of literary excellence and, in the most moving of poetry and prose, convey the noblest thoughts and sentiments – but nobody has ever done so using the Quran’s particular style.

And what an elusive style it has proven to be! The Quran is neither in Arabic prose nor in what is acknowledged as Arabic verse.  It is not written in a combination of both prose and poetry, but in neither of those modes.  It is unique.  At the same time, the Quran is internally consistent in maintaining its unique style.

Only the Quran achieves the highest level of literary excellence – so much so that it brings people to ecstasy and tears – while maintaining this style.

This, then, is the acid test: Write something in the exact same style as the Quran and in doing so produce something of arguably similar quality and sublimity.

Still, one could argue that the evaluation of the results is still grounded in subjective literary tastes.  This is agreed.  However, the second part of the challenge is to bring witnesses to attest to the quality of that evaluation, not just to stand there and make the claim.

Throughout history, people have attempted to write in the style of the Quran.  The results have always been so laughable that no one would venture to say that he believes the effort equals the Quran in literary merit.  The reason why no one would dare do so is not the fear of reprisal – as some skeptics have suggested – but rather the fear of looking like a complete idiot.  One early example was:

Al-Feel
Mal-Feel
Wa maa adraaka mal-feel
Lahu dhanabun radheel, wa khurtoomun taweel 


…which translates as:

The Elephant –
What is the elephant?
And what would have you know what the elephant is?
It has a scraggly tail and a very long trunk.

We can grant that this is a successful attempt at imitating the superficial style of the Quran.  It is clearly modeled after the opening verses of Surah al-Qaari`ah or Surah al-Haaqqah.  However, with such fare on offer, it is no surprise that people are unwilling to stake their reputation on attesting to its literary excellence.

We should pause to consider: What other literary style can we think of which has produced an indisputably great work of literature but is at the same time guaranteed to bring the most wretched failure to anyone else who tries his hand at it?

Generally, it is not a bad idea for a writer to emulate a successful style.  However, a challenge to produce a single chapter like the Quran – the shortest chapter being merely three verses of modest length – has proven impossible to meet. 

Source: Islamland

By: Editorial of islom.uz portal


Related articles
We believe in the Torah, the Gospel, and the Psalms, as Allah says in His Quran. We also believe that Allah has sent down other books and pages except them. But only Allah knows their names and numbers. This is clear in the following versesaposaposAnd It Quran is in the scriptures of the more...

863 10:43 / 20.02.2020
From Abu Saeed, that the Messenger of Allah peace and blessings of Allah be upon him said quotAllah said aposWhoever is too busy with the Quran for remembering Me and asking Me, then I shall give him more than what I give to those who ask.apos And the virtue of Allahaposs Speech over the speech of more...

1711 12:47 / 16.09.2019
In the Name of Allah, The Most Merciful and The Most Compassionate.May His blessings and peace be on His Beloved Prophet, the best of creation, and on his family, companions and followers.There are many ways to become closer to the Creator, and one of the most effective is visiting our Prophet more...

760 13:27 / 15.01.2020
aposThey were not commanded except to worship Allah, being sincere to Him in religion, inclining to truth, and to establish prayer and to give charity, for that is the correct religionapos Surah AlBayyinah, 5And Allah saidaposTheir meat will not reach Allah, nor will their blood, but rather what more...

809 14:34 / 22.01.2020
Tazkiya
HADITH OF THE DAY
Anas ibn Malik radiallahu anhu reported Allahaposs Messenger peace be upon him having said on the day of Nahr SacrificeHe who slaughtered the animal as a sacrifice before the aposId prayer, should repeat it i. e. offer another animal. Thereupon a person stood up and said Messenger of Allah, that is more...